Can Aadhar card be considered as proof of date of birth? Delhi High Court gave a big decision


Today Aadhaar Card has become the most important document for every citizen of the country. Be it opening a bank account, availing the benefits of government schemes or proving your identity somewhere, Aadhar card is the first thing asked for everywhere. But when it comes to proving date of birth, there is often confusion among common people as well as government and private institutions. Now the Delhi High Court, located in the country’s capital, has given a very clear and historic decision on this important legal question. The court has bluntly said that Aadhaar card in itself is not a concrete or final proof of a person’s date of birth. The bench of Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri made it clear that the main purpose of the Aadhaar number is to establish the identity of a person and not to determine his exact age or date of birth. This decision of the court has become a big example for employed employees, employers and common citizens.

This case came before the Delhi High Court regarding the dispute related to the termination of the employment of a female employee. According to the facts of the petition, a woman named Rosamma Joy was working with ‘M/s J. J. Was working in a company named ‘Electronics’. In the year 2017, the company management relieved him from service saying that he had completed the retirement age of 58 years. The company cited the woman’s Aadhar card as the reason behind its decision, in which her date of birth was recorded as May 20, 1959. On the other hand, the female employee approached the Labor Court calling her dismissal illegal. The woman said that in the official records of the Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC), her date of birth is recorded as 20 May 1960. Accordingly, in the year 2017, she had not reached the retirement age and the company forcibly fired her from the job a year earlier. The Labor Court ruled in favor of the woman and ordered her to pay her back wages, against which the company had filed a petition in the Delhi High Court.

While hearing the case, Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri of Delhi High Court rejected the company’s petition outright and completely justified the decision of the Labor Court. The High Court clarified in its order that under the provisions of the Aadhaar Act, 2016, the Aadhaar card has been given legal recognition only as a proof of residence and identity. There is no provision anywhere in this law that considers Aadhaar as conclusive proof of date of birth. The court also specifically referred to the Office Memorandum issued by the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) on December 20, 2018. As per UIDAI rules, the date of birth at the time of Aadhaar enrollment is often recorded on the basis of self-declaration given by the applicant or documents without thorough verification. In such a situation, if the pre-existing official government records (such as ESIC records or school certificate) and the Aadhaar card have different dates regarding the age of a person, then an employee cannot be prematurely retired on the basis of Aadhaar card alone.

This decision of Delhi High Court is not limited only to Delhi-NCR, but is very important for crores of working people across the country including Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra. Earlier, Allahabad High Court and many other High Courts of the country have also made it clear in different cases that Aadhaar card is not a valid document to prove age. It is often seen that in rural and urban areas, while making Aadhaar card, due to clerical error or lack of information, the date of birth of people is recorded wrongly, for example, only January 1 is written as the date of birth on the Aadhaar card of many people. If this Aadhaar card is accepted as the final truth, then lakhs of people may have to suffer huge losses in government jobs, pension, PF (EPFO) claims, insurance policies and legal matters. After this clear stand of the High Court, now no private or government organization will be able to make arbitrary changes in the service record of any employee merely on the basis of the date recorded in the Aadhar card.

According to legal experts and government rules, if you have to get a passport made, get age verified in a government or private job, prove your age in court or have your date of birth recorded in any legal document, then instead of Aadhaar card, only authentic documents should be used. Among the most solid and universally accepted proofs of the date of birth, the Birth Certificate issued by the Municipal Corporation, Gram Panchayat or Registrar comes at the top. Apart from this, class 10th i.e. high school marksheet and certificate (Matriculation Certificate), passport, PAN Card, driving license and Government Service Book (Service Book) or ESIC record are accepted as valid legal evidence of date of birth. Therefore citizens are advised to keep the date of birth consistent in all their official documents and always keep the birth certificate or high school certificate safe to avoid any dispute.