Supreme Court’s big order on ethanol supply dispute, ban on allocation from Q2, AIDA welcomed


New Delhi / Bengaluru: A very important legal news related to the country’s energy and biofuel sector has come to light. The country’s highest court, the Supreme Court, while hearing the ethanol supply allocation dispute, has given major instructions to the oil marketing companies (OMCs). Justice M.M. Sundaresh and Justice Prasanna B. Varale’s bench has restrained Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited (BPCL), Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (HPCL) and Indian Oil Corporation (IOC) from making any new or additional ethanol allocation beyond the second quarter (Q2) of the ethanol supply year (ESY) 2025-26. After this interim order of the Supreme Court, the status quo will remain on the existing system of ethanol allocation in the entire country. The Supreme Court has fixed December 2 for the next detailed hearing of the case. At the same time, the country’s leading distillery organization All India Distillers Association (AIDA) has strongly welcomed this decision of the Supreme Court, calling it a step to bring stability and fairness in the industry.

The root of this entire controversy is the June 16 order of the Karnataka High Court, in which the court had directed the oil marketing companies to reconsider the application of a private ethanol producing company ‘Vinp Distilleries and Sugars’ to increase the allocation. In fact, the annual production capacity of this dedicated ethanol manufacturing company based in Karnataka is about 9.90 crore litres. The company had bid to supply 9.26 crore liters of ethanol for the ethanol supply year 2025-26 (November to October), but only 3.92 crore liters were allotted to it by the oil companies. The company had challenged this cut in the Karnataka High Court, arguing that it had entered into a long-term offtake agreement with the oil companies in the year 2022, hence it should get more allocation on priority basis. The Karnataka High Court, while ruling in favor of the company, had asked the oil companies to reopen the allocation.

Public sector oil company Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited (BPCL) and other oil marketing companies had approached the Supreme Court against this order of the Karnataka High Court. The oil companies’ argument was that if the allocation process was reopened for any one company, it would lead to distilleries in other states across the country moving courts with similar demands, thereby derailing the entire National Ethanol Blending Policy (E20) and supply chain. Considering the seriousness of the matter, Justice M.M. Sundaresh and Justice Prasanna B. Varale’s bench stayed any fresh allocation beyond the second quarter. However, the Supreme Court has also made it clear in its order that if the Central Government or the oil companies feel the need to make any changes in an unavoidable situation, the Attorney General of India R. Venkataramani is free to mention the matter before the court.

The All India Distillers Association (AIDA) has openly welcomed the decision of the Supreme Court to ban fresh allocation from the second quarter. Association officials say that ethanol production is a capital-intensive industry, involving investments worth thousands of crores of rupees from states like Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh and Punjab. According to AIDA, frequent changes in allocation policies mid-season or additional quota being given to selected companies create an environment of uncertainty for distillery operators and farmers providing raw materials across the country. The association said that this interim order of the Supreme Court will not only preserve the sanctity of the contracts but will also ensure a level playing field for all ethanol producers till the final hearing on December 2.

The Government of India has almost achieved the ambitious target of 20 percent ethanol blending (E20) in petrol and grain-based distillery units have played the biggest role in this success. According to recent data, grain-based sources like corn and surplus rice account for more than 73 percent of the country’s total ethanol supply. At a time when the Central Government has imposed some restrictions on direct ethanol production from sugarcane juice to maintain domestic sugar availability, the responsibility of maize producing farmers and grain based plants has increased further. This case, pending in the Supreme Court, is now keeping an eye on lakhs of farmers and hundreds of distillery owners from major sugarcane and maize producing states like Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra and Karnataka.

Legal and energy experts believe that the hearing in the Supreme Court on December 2 will prove to be a milestone in deciding the future direction of India’s biofuels sector. On that day, the court will decide how to balance the allocation between dedicated distilleries having long-term purchase agreements (LTOA) and general bidders. Along with this, the Supreme Court has already sought answers from the Central Government regarding the availability of fuel for vehicles running on 100 percent ethanol (E100) and empowerment of farmers. In such a situation, in the coming days, the entire industry of the country will keep an eye on the legal debate between the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas of the Central Government, oil companies and the Distillery Association.