Supreme Court strongly reprimands Sanjay Raut for his controversial remarks on CJI and Judiciary.


At present, a very big, sensational and legal uproar news is coming out related to the tussle between the Indian Judiciary, the Supreme Court of the country and political statements. Senior MP and firebrand leader of Shiv Sena (UBT) implicated in the case of allegedly making objectionable and controversial comments in public against the Chief Justice of India (CJI) and the entire judicial system. Sanjay Raut Appeared in person before the Supreme Court on Tuesday. The division bench of the Supreme Court, hearing the case of criminal contempt filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA), took a sharp dig at Sanjay Raut’s working style and his apology and bluntly said that “Forgiveness should always come from the heart, not from the mind or show.” This tough stance and harsh comments of the court have created panic in the political circles. Let us know in detail what happened during this high-profile hearing held in the Supreme Court on Tuesday and what is the background of this entire controversy.

Sanjay Raut appeared personally before the bench of Justices Arvind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi.

On Tuesday, this very serious case was heard before the division bench of Supreme Court Justice Arvind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi. Earlier, the Supreme Court had issued a show cause notice to Sanjay Raut for making statements that hurt the dignity of the Chief Justice and the judiciary, following which Sanjay Raut himself appeared in the court on Tuesday.

At the beginning of the hearing, when it was raised that an apology or affidavit had been filed in the court on behalf of MP Sanjay Raut, the bench expressed strong objection to it. Seeing the seriousness of the matter, Justice Arvind Kumar addressed Raut in a very strict tone and said, “The apology should come from the heart, not from the mind. Sanjay Raut ji, you are a senior leader and have probably been in active politics for more than 25 years. We have been listening to you for a long time in different political debates and forums. What do you have to say about this kind of conduct and statements of yours?” After these sharp questions from the court, Sanjay Raut’s lawyer asked for time from the court and said that he will file another new and detailed affidavit in this case.

“Apology given, but conduct is consistently contemptuous”: SCBA President Pradeep Rai’s strong arguments

During the hearing, President of the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) and senior advocate Pradeep Rai presented his case in a very aggressive manner before the court. He told the court that even though an apology has been submitted by Sanjay Raut, his conduct on ground and on social media has consistently amounted to contempt of court.

Drawing the attention of the court, the SCBA president said that when notice was issued in this case on October 16 and then Raut gave an apology on October 26, during that time he did not even mention his other very objectionable social media post. He said that Raut had shared a picture of the Supreme Court of Albania being set on fire or burnt on social media, which clearly shows his bigotry against the judiciary. The senior advocate urged the court that the cases of people who repeatedly commit such acts as a habitual contemnor should be looked into very strictly, so that the supreme dignity and institutional sanctity of the judiciary of the country is not affected.

What is the whole matter? Show cause notice was issued on 16 October

This entire legal controversy started when the Chief Justice of India (CJI) had turned down the request made by a delegation of some opposition parties of the country seeking a personal meeting, citing formal rules. The CJI had clearly given the message that any issue related to administrative or political dispute should be brought before the court through a duly formal petition instead of raising it orally.

Only after this decision, a round of comments started in political and media circles. The contempt petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) alleged that following this, journalist Nikhil Wagle and MP Sanjay Raut circulated highly derogatory and objectionable comments against the judiciary and especially the CJI on the social media platform ‘X’ and other public forums. Seeing the seriousness of this matter, Attorney General of India R. Venkataramani had also given his formal consent to initiate criminal contempt proceedings against the two under Section 15(1)(b) of the ‘Contempt of Courts Act, 1971’. On this basis, on October 16, the Supreme Court had issued a show cause notice to both of them and sought their reply, and now the next legal process of this case is progressing rapidly.