
There has been a huge uproar regarding aviation safety after the tragic death of 6 people in the helicopter accident of Trans Bharat Aviation returning from Badrinath Dham to Dehradun on Friday on the Chardham Yatra route of Uttarakhand. Immediately after this fatal accident, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has taken a tough stance and made it mandatory for all single-engine chartered helicopters flying in the Chardham sector to deploy ‘two pilots’ (chief pilot and co-pilot) with immediate effect. However, helicopter operators have mobilized against this strict order implemented in the name of security. Operators clearly say that this rule imposed without any prior consultation is impractical and will cause huge financial crisis. The angry operators have given an ultimatum to the DGCA and the Uttarakhand Civil Aviation Development Authority (UCADA) and announced a complete halt to all chartered helicopter services to Chardham from November 2, creating a major crisis for thousands of pilgrims arriving for darshan just before the doors are closed.
This strict action of the aviation regulator has come to light after the tragic accident that took place near Badrinath Dham on the afternoon of 30 October. Trans Bharat Aviation’s helicopter VT-HCX, which was carrying five pilgrims from Badrinath to Sahastradhara helipad in Dehradun, lost contact at Swari Khark near Hathi Parvat in Joshimath valley. Shortly afterwards, it was confirmed that the helicopter had crashed, in which all six passengers, including five devotees from Karnataka and pilot Captain Himanshu, resident of Delhi, died on the spot. Amidst serious questions being raised regarding the repeated incidents of heli accidents in the Himalayan region, special teams of DGCA and Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) conducted an aerial survey of the incident site and started investigating the safety lapses. After this, DGCA gave clear instructions that now in sensitive and inaccessible hilly areas, flights cannot be operated with the help of only one pilot and presence of two qualified pilots will be mandatory in every flight.
The new safety manual issued by DGCA is not limited to the deployment of only two pilots, but the entire system of flight operations has been tied into a strict monitoring mechanism. Under the new rules, written or digital permission of UCADA’s Heli Operation Officer (HOO) has now been made mandatory for every takeoff and landing. Before taking off, final approval of the destination, weather and route will have to be taken from the nodal officer posted at Sahastradhara or Sonprayag helipad. After landing, the pilot will have to immediately submit a written report to the control room, on the basis of which permission for the next flight will be given. In view of the difficulties operators are facing in getting co-pilots, the regulator has also given relaxation that they can appoint pilots of other companies as co-pilots with mutual coordination and experienced pilots above 60 years of age can also be deployed as co-pilots.
As soon as this order of DGCA came, the Helicopter Operators Association started strongly opposing it. The operators have sent a joint letter to the DGCA chief alleging that this decision has been taken in haste without understanding the ground reality. The companies argue that by deploying two pilots on every flight, the salary of the pilots, their stay in the hilly areas, travel and logistics expenses will increase manifold. Between the current chartered rates and pre-booked packages, companies cannot bear this heavy financial burden from their own pockets. Additionally, due to the extremely thin air density of the Himalayas and strict weight limitations, the seating of a second pilot will reduce the payload capacity of the helicopter, which will create technical difficulties in carrying passengers or their luggage. Operators say it is practically impossible to suddenly ensure availability of so many qualified and trained pilots for mountain flights.
Due to this protest by the operators, the entire chartered heli network of Chardham Yatra has been locked since November 2. According to officials of Uttarakhand Civil Aviation Development Authority (UCADA), many major companies have given formal notice to the authority to cancel the advance booking of their remaining flights, expressing their inability to comply with the new rules. Now only a few days are left for the conclusion of the Yatra season and between 10th and 15th November the doors of Badrinath and Kedarnath are going to be closed for winter. The sudden stoppage of chartered flights at such a crucial juncture is a big blow to those VIPs, elderly and ailing devotees who had booked helicopter packages months ago after spending lakhs of rupees. In case of cancellation of booking, now devotees have to struggle between the options of refund and traveling by road.
Aviation experts believe that the Chardham airspace is one of the most challenging and unpredictable flight corridors in the country, where fog, strong winds and clouds reduce visibility to zero in the blink of an eye. In such an environment, any compromise with safety standards can invite more major accidents in future, hence DGCA’s stand is completely justified. On the other hand, there is substance in the demand of the operators that instead of suddenly implementing such a major policy change in the last 10 days of the journey, it should have been implemented in a phased manner by holding a joint meeting with the operators, UCADA and technical experts. For the time being, unless a practical agreement is reached between the DGCA and the aviation companies, the buzz of helicopters in the Himalayan valleys is likely to remain silent and the dispute will deepen further.
look news india